Wednesday, August 28, 2013

Does it take two for positive change in a relationship? Can one person do it alone?

From time to time I've had individual patients come to me requesting marriage counseling.  "Where's your spouse?" I ask them.  The reply: "He/she refuses to come."  My response has always been to explain that marriage counseling requires the participation of both partners; you simply cannot do marriage counseling alone.  But is this really true?

Change on the part of one person can certainly alter the dynamics of a relationship.  A dynamic is by definition an interactive system or process.  Change in one part of a system therefore changes the dynamics of that system.  An inter-action requires at least two individuals, each responding to the other.  Person A says or does something; person B says or does something in response.  Person A responds to what person B has just said or done; person B then responds to person A, and so on and so forth until the interaction is over.  Because humans are creatures of habit, two people in a relationship begin to develop "typical" ways of interacting with one another over time.  These sytles of interaction become increasingly automatic and are repeated across a variety of situations; they solidify into identifiable patterns.  If these patterns facilitate effective communication and serve to enhance the relationship the relationship will most likely thrive.  Sometimes the patterns of interaction between two people are dysfunctional: they interfere with effective communication and perpetuate conflict.  If the couple does not learn to interact in healthier ways their relationship becomes toxic and will probably not last. 

One person can disrupt unhealthy patterns of interaction in a relationship; it takes two to tango, so to speak.  To do this, one person in the relationship must choose to alter his or her reaction to the other person's behavior.  It only takes one person, for example, to walk away instead of engaging in conflict.  One person can choose to stop making demands of the other and learn to accept that their partner is not going to comply, give in, or otherwise do what they're being asked (or told) to do.  One person can decide not to become defensive when their partner makes a negative comment.  One partner can stop bringing up a topic that leads to arguments. 

There are a lot of things one person can do, particularly if the goal is to reduce overt conflict and/or confrontation.  And sometimes change in one partner can lead to change in the other.  The key word is sometimes. 

On the other hand, one person cannot "fix" a broken relationship.  One person cannot coerce another to acitvely participate in a relationship.  One person cannot force another to care about his or her wants and needs.  One person cannot convince another person to share his or her desires. 

If a person wants help in reducing conflict in his or her marriage then there are things I can do to help.  It is important, however, for the person to understand that this might mean accepting the behavior of his or her partner, even if the behavior in question is not really acceptable (e.g., cheating).   

Wednesday, August 21, 2013

Can a therapist with problems still be a good therapist?

I sometimes wonder why, in my personal life, I am not more competent interpersonally than I am.  In fact, for someone who spends a significant amount of time helping people learn to interact with one another I often find my own lack of skill in such matters embarassing.  I wonder if it is possible to be a good psychotherapist when I sometimes struggle with issues similar to those facing my patients.  Can I really help people learn to overcome problems I myself have not successfully mastered?  Can I teach others to do things I myself am not able to do?  And if not, does that mean I am not a good psychotherapist?  Am I doing my patients a disservice?  Do my personal limitations prevent me from providing adequate care?

Then again, I know I am not the only psychotherapist facing this problem.  I thinks about other therapists I know, colleagues both former and current.  Many of them have struggled in their personal lives.  Ironically, one of the best marriage therapists I've ever encountered has been married and divorced at least twice.  And yet, I refer my patients to him again and again, confidently touting his skill and expertise.  When I talk to patients who have seen him with their spouse for ocunseling, they always give positive feedback about the experience.  As good as he is at marriage therapy, however, he is apparently not that good at marriage. 

If a skilled marriage therapist can be terrible at marriage, it stands to reason that a competent psychotherapist can have unresolved personal problems.

Of course I decided to do some research.  In doing so, I stumbled upon an article written by an historic icon in the field of psychotherapy, Carl Rogers.  There was something in particular he said in the article that brought me peace of mind.  In the article, he proposes a theory in which he identifies the conditions necessarry for positive therapeutic change to occur.  One of six identified conditions is that the therapist be "a congruent, genuine, integrated person" within the context of his relationship with the patient.  He goes on to say that it is neither necessarry nor possible for the therapist to be "a paragon who exhibits this degree of integration, of wholeness, in every aspect of his life.  It is sufficient that he is accurately himself in this hour of this relationship..."

What a relief.  I don't have to have it all together all the time to be a good therapist.  I just need to bring my healthiest self each time I interact with a patient.

Wednesday, August 14, 2013

Stress

I realized quite some time ago that I don't handle stress very well.  This may seem strange coming from a psychotherapist.  Isn't a significant part of my job to teach people how to deal with stress?  Yes and no.

Learning to cope with stress effectively is certainly a goal for a lot of my patients.  But I think this means different things for different people.  For many people, effective coping involves limiting the amount of stress they expose themselves to (at least to whatever degree possible).  For example, if I am in the middle of a major life transition it is probably not a good time for me to take on a new project (unless I have to).

Here's another example.  Let's say I am someone who likes my home to be clean and tidy at all times.  Now suppose my spouse invites a large group of extended family members to spend the week with us.  Knowing this in advance, I might spend extra time cleaning up before they arrive and then give myself permission not to worry about trying to keep things tidy until after my guests leave.  (Because I can either spend my week trying to clean up after everyone and make myself miserable or I can spend quality time with people I love and enjoy myself). 

So because I know I have a low tolerance for stress I do my best to limit the amount of stress in my life at any given time.  Historically, this has been a pretty effective strategy.  Recently, however, there have been problems.  This is due, in part, to the fact that my husband believes I should be able to handle more stress than I do.  In making his case, he tells a story about how he used to worry about everything.  One day, he realized how miserable this made him.  He decided he no longer wanted to be miserable.  From that day forward, he resolved to stop letting things bother him.  He has been happy ever since.  The end.

It's a great story.  He makes a good point: excessive worrying does tend to make people miserable.  I know this.  And honestly, over the years I have learned to let a lot of things go.  What I think my husband fails to understand is that his experience of stress and my experience of stress are fundamentally different.  By nature, my husband is not easily exciteable.  His disposition is cheerful by default.  He likes to have fun and makes doing fun things a top priority.  When forced to choose between fulfilling some obligation (which can of course always be put off until later) and doing something fun, nine times out of ten he will choose to do something fun.

I, on the other hand, have apparently always been discontent.  My parents tell me I suffered from severe colic as an infant.  As a result, I cried a lot and was frequently inconsolable.  I can remember worrying about all sorts of random things as early as age four.  By the age of five, I had developed so many compulsive behaviors that my kindergarten teacher called my parents to express concern.  After a visit to a psychologist I was diagnosed with Obsessive Compulsive Disorder.  At the age of five.

So in my view, the cards were stacked against me from the start.  I have been dealing with anxiety for literally my entire life.  To me, the fact that I've been able to find peace in my life is remarkable.  And yet I do have peace.  Not all the time.  But I do have it, and I am grateful. 

On the other hand, maybe it would be good to push myself harder.  My husband says I need to spend more time outside of my comfort zone.  I'll admit that I've been a little resistant to this.  My comfort zone is where I have peace.  What if I stray too far and am unable to find my way back?  What if I upset the delicate balance I have worked so hard to achieve?

Then again, I believe we should never stop growing as individuals.  I have grown a lot over the years but that does not mean I am finished.  Who knows what I am missing out on while I stay here in my comfort zone? 

Wednesday, August 7, 2013

Selfish

I think most of us are selfish, at least to a certain degree.  It's quite natural when you think about it.  We see things from our own perspectives and are influenced by our own thoughts and emotions.  This happens automatically, without effort.  We exist within our own bodies from the moment we are born.  And yet, no matter how much time we spend with ourselves there are always things we don't understand.  Why do I get upset over some particular thing?  Why do I have certain fears?  Why don't I have as much energy as other people?  Why do I worry so much?  Why can't I focus?  Why am I good at one thing but not at another? For every person, there is a part of himself that remains a bit of a mystery.

As difficult as it is to know ourselves, it is even more difficult to understand others.  In order to try to see things from someone else's perspective, we must first set aside our natural inclination to see things from our own perspective.  We must then imagine how that person sees the world.  This is easier to do in situations that are similar to those we've experienced ourselves; we can recall how we thought and felt.  Still, this strategy rests on the assumption that the person we are trying to understand reacts to the situation in question with the same thoughts and feelings we ourselves had.  This may or may not be the case.

It seems to me that the natural inclination is to see things from our own perspectives and to act accordingly; we are thus all inclined to be a bit selfish.  Empathizing with others requires intention and effort.  When we are under a lot of stress or when we are tired, sick, hungry, or distressed, we may lack the energy or the presence of mind to empathize with others.  These are the times when we are most likely to behave selfishly, often without even realizing it.

I've been thinking about this because someone recently accused me of being selfish.  My first reaction was to become defensive; I felt I was being judged, and unfairly at that.  It bothered me though.  I'm not selfish, am I?  I care about other people.  I constantly think about the people I love.  I call them.  I spend time with them.  I tell them I love them.

What does it mean to be selfish anyway?  Almost certainly it means different things to different people.  As I said before, I think everyone is a little bit selfish and I don't necessarally think it's a bad thing.  There are times when we need to put ourselves first.

Still, I've been thinking...Maybe I put myself first too often.  It is something to consider...     

Wednesday, July 31, 2013

Dissociation

The meaning of dissociation is found in the word itself: dis-association.  Dissociation occurs when a person’s mind dis-associates with his or her body.  This is not the technical definition of the term, but it’s where I start when I explain it to patients.  (The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders defines dissociation thus: A disruption in the usually integrated function of consciousness, memory, identity, or perception of the environment).  When a person dissociates, his body stays in one place while his mind sort of goes somewhere else. 
Dissociation is not necessarily pathological.  In fact, everyone dissociates.  Have you ever driven an oft-travelled route - perhaps heading to work or driving home – and arrived at your destination to find that you have no recollection of the actual journey (perhaps because you were daydreaming or otherwise absorbed in your thoughts)?  That’s dissociation.  Another example of dissociation is the experience of “flow:” we become totally absorbed in some task or activity such that we are completely unaware of our surroundings, to include the passage of time.  When we look at the clock, we are surprised to find that several hours have passed in what seemed like only minutes. 
So in certain forms, dissociation is a normal and quite common experience.  In extreme forms, however, dissociation can become disruptive and therefore problematic.  Probably the most severe manifestation of dissociation is in Dissociative Identity Disorder.  (Some of you might know it as Multiple Personality Disorder).  The identity or self of any given person is made up of various parts or components.  For example, there is a part of me who is compassionate and benevolent and another part of me who is petty and vindictive.  There is a part of me who is responsible and a part of me that is reckless.  I will think, feel, and even behave differently depending on which part of my “self” is activated at any given time.  Even though my identity consists of many different parts I am still only one person.  There is an overall cohesiveness among the different parts of myself.  There is some sort of “observing ego” that stands back from it all, that intimately knows each individual “part” of my identity, and that holds all the pieces together.  A person with Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID) does not have this “observing ego.”  The various parts of a person with DID are completely separate and unaware of one another.  They do not share memories and they do not share information.  One part has no awareness of what another part does, even though they all reside in the same physical body. 
Fortunately, Dissociative Identity Order is extremely rare.  In fact, there has historically been quite a bit of debate about whether it exists at all.  I have only ever worked with one person who was diagnosed with DID and I suspect the diagnosis was incorrect.
I have, however, worked with many patients who struggle with other forms of dissociation.  I’ve had several patients who recalled experiences in which they were outside of their bodies, seeing themselves but having no control over what they were doing.  One person saw herself go into a store, buy a bottle of pills, and take the entire bottle.  She said she was screaming at herself to stop but was powerless to prevent her own suicide attempt. Another person was involved in a serious industrial accident.  He described being outside of his body, watching himself curl up on the ground and scream with pain.  He told himself to get up but to no avail. 
Other patients have no recollection of what happened during dissociative episodes.  They simply report “losing time.”  One woman regained awareness to find herself in an unfamiliar city with no idea how she’d gotten there.  She’d somehow driven 75 miles without meaning to.  Another patient became anxious while driving and decided to pull off the road to calm himself down.  He remembers looking at the clock as he pulled off.  The next thing he remembers is looking at the clock again and seeing that over an hour has passed.  He has no idea what he did during that hour.
Dissociation fascinates me.  How can someone’s mind wander away from his body?  I imagine it is a scary thing to know that your body has been doing things without your knowledge (or consent).  I’ll talk about what causes dissociation and how to treat it in future posts.

Wednesday, July 24, 2013

Narcolepsy

I have narcolepsy.  It's not something I talk about a lot, especially not online.  Because I don't talk much about it, it seems like the people closest to me don't really consider how it affects me.  For example, my husband frequently becomes frustrated when I say I'm too tired to do something.  Take a recent Saturday for example.  At 7:00 AM, my stepdaughter and I met my sister, parents, and some extended family for a two mile charity walk.  Afterwards, my husband, stepdaugther, and I went to the beach and took the jet ski out.  The following morning my family met up at 9 AM for a Father's Day breakfast.  We all went to church afterwards.  As church let out, my sister mentioned that she and her husband were taking my nieces to the water park.  She invited us to meet them there.  My husband and stepdaughter went but I just couldn't do it.  I went home and napped for two hours.  When I got up, I finished doing laundry and went to the grocery store.  Later in the week, my husband commented on how active my sister is.  He said he wished I could be that way instead of only doing "one activity per weekend."  A couple of weeks later he told my stepdaughter that I'm boring because I never want to do anything.  He didn't understand when I told him his comment hurt my feelings.  "You don't like to do anything," he said, as if stating a fact.

It bothers me.  It's not that I don't want to do things.  It's just that I know myself.  I have a good idea of what would've happened if, for example, I had forced myself to go to the water park that day.  I would have been extremely irritable (because I was tired) and unpleasant to be around.  I probably would have wanted to go home well before everyone else was ready.  I would not have had the energy to do laundry and go to the grocery store when we got home, even though these things had to be done and no one else was going to do them.  And I would have been exhausted at work the following day and struggled to stay awake.  It's possible I might have fallen asleep at some inopportune moment, such as when driving to work on in the middle of a session with a patient.

I have no idea if everyone with narcolepsy has the same struggles.  I don't know anyone else with narcolepsy so I have no one to compare myself to.  (Incidentally, I have had two patients with narcolepsy over the years but I didn't think it was particularly appropriate to discuss my experiences with them).  I can't say whether or not my experiences are "normal" or "typical."  I do the best I can and I try not to dwell on my limitations.  Dealing with it is frustrating but I am grateful that things aren't worse - I know they could be.  I wonder, though, if there isn't some way to help the people closest to me understand without making it seem like I'm throwing myself a pity party. 

Tuesday, July 16, 2013

What makes a relationship last?

My husband and I have been married three years in November.  I wish I could say that I’ve learned a lot about what it takes to make a marriage work during the past three years.  I suppose I could say it, but it wouldn’t be entirely true and I’m not a huge fan of lying.  It’s not that I haven’t learned anything in the past three years.  It’s just that I haven’t been able to successfully apply the knowledge I’ve gained in any meaningful way. 
Here’s what I do know: Marriage is hard!  I realize this isn’t very insightful.  While I am usually a fairly introspective person, I find it very difficult to reflect on and understand my thoughts, feelings, motivations, and behaviors as they apply to my relationship with my husband.  And if it’s hard for me to make sense of myself, I often find it impossible to understand my husband. 
All this makes me wonder, what does it take for a marriage to work anyway?  So of course, I decided to do some research.  I discovered that there has been a lot of research done on this topic.  This research has led to the development of many different theories about what makes a successful marriage.  While each study generated a different list of variables associated with marital success, there were some common themes. 
*Communication: I wasn’t surprised to find good communication repeatedly identified as a factor associated with successful marriages.  Healthy communication allows a couple to understand one another; this enables partners to validate and empathize with each other.  Good communication facilitates allows day to day activities to run smoothly.  (Frequent miscommunication creates unnecessary crises.  For example, miscommunication about where to be and what time to be there can lead to confusion and disappointment.  Important tasks go uncompleted.  Problems arise.  Plans have to be changed, sometimes drastically.  More time is spent trying to fix problems caused by miscommunication, leaving less time for enjoyable activities that would strengthen the relationship).  Good communication also promotes successful conflict resolution.  It prevents disagreements from inevitably turning into arguments.
*Conflict management/resolution: This one didn’t surprise me either.  Couples who can resolve conflict have less conflict.  Successful conflict resolution prevents the same problems from arising again and again.  The ability to compromise leads to the development of solutions that leave both partners feeling loved and respected.  Time isn’t wasted arguing over who is right or who is to blame.  Both partners understand that if one person wins, the other one loses.  If one person loses, the whole relationship loses.  Thus, blaming always has a negative impact on the relationship.    
*Trust: I’ve always heard that you can’t have a relationship without trust – at least not a good one.  The presence or absence of trust impacts the level of security a person experiences in a relationship.  Security – a sense of safety – is one of the most fundamental of human needs.  An individual’s basic needs must be met before higher-level development can occur.  Thus, an absence of trust prevents a relationship from growing.  Distance emerges between two partners.  The relationship becomes dominated by feelings of doubt, fear, and hurt. 
There is a final factor that I believe deserves at least an honorable mention: commitment.  Commitment is the belief – held by both partners – that a relationship is permanent.  Commitment also describes a set of behaviors devoted to maintaining a relationship, even (and especially) when things are not going well.  When people are committed to a marriage, they are willing to do whatever it takes, again and again, to make the relationship work.  If one strategy does not work, they try something else.  Commitment is also characterized by the willingness of both partners to make personal sacrifices for the good of the relationship.

Sunday, July 7, 2013

Loneliness

To me there's always seemed to be a bit of irony inherent to the experience of loneliness.  One the one hand, loneliness is inextricably linked to the connections an individual has to other people.  People feel lonely when they spend too much time by themselves and not enough time with others.  On the other hand, there is a component of loneliness that seems to have no relationship at all to being alone versus being with other people.  Thus, a person can spend significant amounts of time by himself and not feel the slightest bit lonely.  A person can also be in a room overflowing with people and yet feel utterly and completely alone.  And so I've come to realize that loneliness is a phenomenon more complex than at first it seems.

Loneliness is a virtually universal experience; almost everyone experiences it at least once in a lifetime.  Almost all of us have an idea of what it means to be lonely, even if we can't exactly put it into words.  If I say to someone, "I feel lonely," he understands what I mean; I don't have to explain it.  Perhaps this is why the scientific community has only recently begun to develop a clear definition of loneliness.  For practical purposes, there is no need for a concrete definition of loneliness.  But in order to study a given phenomenon we must be clear about exactly what it is we are studying.  And so the need to define loneliness grew out of an increasing interest among social scientists in better understanding the phenomenon and its effects.

So what exactly is loneliness?  Researchers have identified three characteristics:

1. Loneliness stems from deficiencies in social relationships.

2. Loneliness is a subjective experience.  (In other words, what causes one person to feel lonely does not necessarily cause someone else to feel lonely).

3. Loneliness is both unpleasant and distressing for the person experiencing it.
'(Perlman & Peplau)

Because loneliness is a subjective problem, there are many different ways to go about trying to resolve it.  A person might simply lack good social skills and so find it difficult to make friends.  Others might fear intimacy or have "trust issues."  In such cases, loneliness is really a secondary problem that will most likely resolve itself once the primary concerns are addressed.

When's the last time you can remember feeling lonely?  What caused it?  Were you able to overcome it?  If so, how?

Sunday, June 30, 2013

More common human desires

One desire that seems to be common to almost everyone is the desire to be "normal."  I cannot tell you the relief many patients express  when I tell them their symptoms have a name and that other people share their experience.  Maybe this can be attributed to not wanting to feel alone.  People are comforted to hear that what they are feeling is "normal."  This is why support groups are often helpful.  Connecting with other people who have been through what you've been through or who have thoughts and feelings similar to your own creates a unique bond.  This is related to our need to be understood.  After all, who can understand you better than someone who has had a similar experience or whose suffering in some way mirrors your own?  When we connect with a group of people who have been through similar hardships we experience a sense of belonging. 

Another common need among people is the need for validation.  To validate another person is simply to say, "It is okay to feel what you feel.  It is okay to do what you're doing.  It is okay to be the way you are."  Validation both normalizes and communicates understanding.  It can also serve to remove shame.  People sometimes become convinced that they should not feel how they feel or that there is something wrong with the way they are.  This creates feelings of shame and guilt.  To hear from another person that the way you feel is okay or that there is nothing wrong with the way you are can provide an enormous sense of relief.  In some ways it gives a person permission to experience their feelings freely.

I am frequently struck by how many things seem to be common to all of us.  It reminds me again and again that no matter our differences, most of us want the same things.


Sunday, June 23, 2013

Things people want

As a psychotherapist, I have the unique privilege of witnessing all sorts of human behavior.  While every person is different and no single approach works for everyone I don't necessarally reinvent the wheel every time I encounter a new patient.  One of the reasons therapists tend to become better with experience is because when they meet a new patient they can eventually say to themselves, "I've had a patient with this type of problem before.  I remember what worked (and what didn't work) for him.  Maybe I'll try a similar strategy with this patient."  The longer you've been practicing the more likely you are to have seen even relatively rare variations of a given problem before.  (An unintended side effect: A lot of things seem "normal" to me that would probably seem strange to other people). 

Something else a therapist learns with experience is that even people who are completely different from one another posess common needs and desires.  For example, I've never met anyone, either personally or professionally, who did not have the desire to be understood.  This is something that probably evolved in concert with our capacity for speech and language.  On the most basic level, we want others to comprehend the meaning of what we communicate verbally.  After all, what good is the ability to speak if no one  understands what you're saying?  The significance of human language lies in its utility as a tool for creating common meaning among two or more distinct entities. 

We desire basic comprehension and yet this is not enough,.  We want others to understand us on a deeper level; we want them to really get what we're saying.  One of the most fundamental communication skills is something called reflection.  Reflection involves listening to another person and repeating his message back to him, either exactly as you heard it or in paraphrase or summary.  It sounds simple but it's more difficult than you might think.  So many of us have a habit of hearing a person's words without really listening to what they are saying.  I'll give you an example of a couple I once saw for marriage counseling.  I asked the wife to use an "I statement" to express her feelings to her husband.  The husband was asked to listen and repeat what he heard his wife say.  She started: "I feel frustrated and disappointed when you promise to do something and then do not do it."  Then it was his turn.  "I heard, "nag nag nag nag nag,'" he said.  My jaw dropped in surprise.  The wife started crying.

In sum, there is something profoundly affirming about being understood by another person.  Perhaps it helps us to feel less alone.

I'll share more observations about things people want later...

My Favorites